When evaluating a CRE broker, I’m rarely impressed by the size of the company on their business card. Over the years, I’ve hired hundreds of brokers and learned that the true differentiators lie elsewhere. In fact, I’d argue that working for a large national brokerage firm often doesn’t add significant value to the broker’s career—or to their clients.
Let’s break this down.
The Myth of the Big Brand
It’s easy to assume that a broker working for a national firm automatically has an edge. After all, they’ve got access to vast resources, a recognizable name, and perhaps a network of offices across the country. But how often do those factors truly benefit the client—or the broker?
In my experience, these so-called advantages are often overstated. Most real estate transactions are inherently local. A deal in Manhattan has little to do with one in Miami, regardless of the company’s nationwide presence. What matters most is the broker’s deep understanding of their specific market, not the broader reach of their employer.
What Really Matters: Reputation and Personal Brand
The first thing I look for in a broker isn’t the name on their paycheck; it’s their reputation.
- Are they known for their integrity and follow-through?
- Do they have a personal brand that inspires trust?
Clients aren’t hiring “XYZ National Brokerage.” They’re hiring you. Your ability to build and nurture relationships, solve problems, and deliver results will always outweigh the firm you represent. A strong personal brand that highlights your expertise and credibility is far more valuable than any corporate logo.
Knowledge and Personality Trump All
Another misconception is that brokers at large firms have a knowledge advantage. While it’s true they may have access to training programs, knowledge is something a broker has to actively cultivate—regardless of where they work.
- Do you understand your market better than anyone else?
- Can you explain trends, predict challenges, and offer creative solutions?
- Are you able to break down complex deals in a way that clients can easily understand?
Then there’s personality. Real estate is a people business. A broker who is personable, professional, and relatable will close more deals than someone who relies solely on their company’s resources. Great brokers don’t just know the market—they know how to connect with people.
The Irrelevance of Conflicts and Commission Rates
Interestingly, many people worry about potential conflicts of interest or rigid commission structures when hiring a broker from a national firm. In my experience, these concerns are often overblown.
Conflicts can arise anywhere—whether you’re at a boutique firm or a national one. The key is transparency. If you’re honest about your relationships and interests, most conflicts can be managed effectively.
As for commission rates, clients rarely choose a broker based on who charges the least. They want value. If you can show that you’re worth the investment, you’ll rarely lose a deal over your fee.
The True Game Changer: Communication Cadence
If there’s one thing that separates an average broker from an exceptional one, it’s their ability to communicate consistently and effectively. I can’t stress this enough: developing a great cadence of communication is everything.
Clients want to feel informed without having to chase you for updates. They want to know that you’re on top of the details, proactively addressing potential issues, and keeping them in the loop at every stage of the process.
- Set clear expectations from the beginning.
- Schedule regular check-ins.
- Be responsive and accessible.
These are simple practices, but they’re often overlooked. Mastering them will do more for your career than any national firm’s brand ever could.
The Disadvantages of Large Firms
While large firms may seem appealing, they come with downsides:
- You’re just another number. Brokers at national firms can feel like cogs in a machine, overshadowed by the firm’s identity rather than their own.
- Rigid structures. Larger firms often have more bureaucracy, which can stifle creativity and flexibility in how you approach deals.
- Less personal connection. Clients may feel like they’re dealing with a corporation rather than an individual who truly understands their needs.
The Path Forward: Invest in Yourself
If you’re a broker—or considering hiring one—don’t get caught up in the allure of big names. Instead, focus on these essentials:
- Build your personal brand. Use platforms like LinkedIn to showcase your expertise and successes.
- Master your market. Become the go-to expert for your specific niche or region.
- Hone your communication skills. Make every client interaction professional, clear, and valuable.
- Continuously learn. Stay on top of market trends, technology, and best practices.
- Be authentic. Relationships drive this business. Be someone people trust and want to work with.
Conclusion: The Broker Defines the Value
Ultimately, the broker—not the brokerage—creates value for clients. Your success depends on your reputation, knowledge, personality, and ability to communicate effectively. Working for a large national firm might open some doors, but it won’t keep them open.
Focus on what you can control: your personal brand, your skills, and your relationships. These are the factors that will set you apart—whether you’re at a big firm, a boutique shop, or running your own practice.
Want help growing your business? Schedule a free one on one call with me:
P.S. Whenever you’re ready… here are 4 ways I can help you grow your brokerage business:
1. Grab a free copy of my Ultimate LinkedIn Guide for CRE Brokers
It’s the roadmap to turning your LinkedIn Profile from a boring resume into a powerful Sales & Marketing Funnel to get qualified leads every day — CLICK HERE
2. Join the GROUP COACHING PROGRAM and scale with other brokers like you.
It’s our group/private hybrid coaching program where smart brokers learn to get more income, impact, and independence. If you’d like to get some leads & clients this month, email me HERE with the word GROUP, and I’ll get you all the details.
3. Join our PRIVATE COACHING Program and become an authority in your market
If you’d like to work directly with me and my team to take you from 6 to 7 figures… just send me an email to HERE with the word PRIVATE, tell me a little about your business and what you’d like to work on together, and I’ll get you all the details.
4. Join our PEER ADVISORY GROUP and take your business to the next level.
This exclusive Mastermind program is tailored for visionary leaders, like you, aiming to dominate markets, diversify assets, streamline operations, pivot strategically or prepare for a sale or move firms. This is limited to either current or past PRIVATE clients only
